This is one from the dark ages of Disney
animation, that awful period between Walt Disney’s death in 1966 and the
brief renaissance that was initiated by the Little Mermaid in 1989. At
the same time, though, it’s not quite true that this is a product of the
dark ages since in fact this movie is actually just three Winnie
the Pooh shorts stuck together and the first two shorts (2/3 of the
movie) have their origins from a time when Disney was still alive to make
sure his animators had the fear of God in them.
Based on the
popular children’s stories by English author A.A. Milne this movie is by
nature episodic and disjointed. There is however a clever if somewhat
slapdash attempt to provide a unifying spirit by structuring the stories
around the memories of Christopher Robin, who eventually must abandon
his fantasies of childhood to go off to boarding school, all of which
seem to be built entirely upon a deep seeded loneliness. There’s
actually a hint of tragedy in the premise. I can’t be the only one who
thought that it was sad and strange that Pooh Bear and friends all
existed solely because they are his “imaginary friends”, right?
Anyway the movie quickly moves through a number of charming vignettes
about life in the Hundred Acre Wood, where Christopher Robin played, all
of which are narrated as if the audience is being read to by some great
big burly Nanny. Each short is slightly less appealing than the one
before it, indeed, the last portion of the movie is very bland in
comparison to the first. But what makes the bulk of the stories so
wonderful is how simple and disarmingly mild they are; perfect for small
children or adults who have had a very stressful day. In fact, I dare
anyone who puts on this movie to not be relaxed by watching
Pooh fly up the honey tree on a little balloon.
While there
isn’t much in the way of animation to praise the music fits the tone of
the sheltered childhood fantasy perfectly and is often just as cathartic
as the gentle characters in Christopher Robin’s twisted fantasy world
(save for the Tigger song, which is wild in an awesome way). Also the
stories and delightful characters themselves offer up quite a lot of
effective humor. Everyone, for instance, remembers the story about Pooh
being so fat that he has to live inside Rabbits doorway for days to lose
weight right? What a riot! If it sounds silly, trust me, it’s actually
pretty sweet, especially when a beaver with a speech impediment gets
involved. If you see it and still disagree...well then may God have
mercy on your cynical black heart.
This movie is clearly not
intended to be great filmmaking, it’s just a soothing, charming taste of
English childhood, which I think traditionally comes with a side of blood sausage. In it’s intended end it succeeds, for at least most
of the way. Gradually, it just turns into a Saturday morning cartoon but
by then you and your children might actually be fast asleep anyway.
I give it 3.8 out of 5 honey pots. A happy romp inside a small boy’s
imagination... a sad, somewhat neglected, and sterile imagination.
No comments:
Post a Comment